Sweet Potato Casserole ♥ Recipe

The traditional Sweet Potato Casserole, updated: way-fewer-than-usual mini marshmallows, hints of vanilla and ginger, plus a pecan-panko topping. Delish! #PP4 for #WeightWatchers from #AVeggieVenture
The traditional sweet potato casserole, updated. Think way-fewer-than-usual mini marshmallows, hints of vanilla and ginger, plus a pecan-panko topping. Delish!

~recipe & photo updated 2011~
~more recently updated recipes~

2007: Some holidays, you just don't mess with tradition. But still, call me surprised to feature a recipe for a traditional Thanksgiving sweet potato casserole with marshmallows on top. My taste testers loved this! Good sweet potato flavor really comes through, the texture is soft and pillowy, the sweetness is there but not over the top. But the best part is the topping mixture, mini marshmallows interspersed with crispy bread crumbs spiced with ginger and toasted pecans. If marshmallows are traditional at Thanksgiving, so be it, I'm not messing with tradition!

2011: Whoa. I'd forgotten how good sweet potato casserole can be! This recipe isn't as sweet as many other recipes. Even so, I wouldn't hesitate to serve it for dessert though I'd put on my marketing hat and call it "sweet potato pudding". The topping is delicious and the mixture of marshmallows and pecan-panko crumbs just 'looks' so pretty, which many sweet potato casseroles don't. This is a winner!

"This was the BEST sweet potato casserole I've ever made and eaten! It was a huge hit for Thanksgiving - people ate seconds of this instead of dessert!" ~ Laura


Adapted from an old clipping from Cooking Light
Hands-on time: 40 minutes
Time to table: 90 - 120 minutes
Serves 16 in smallish portions for a large meal with many other choices

Water to cover
2-1/4 pounds sweet potatoes, peeled and cut into pieces roughly the same size
3/4 cup brown sugar
1 teaspoon table salt
2 teaspoons vanilla (don't skip this!)
2 large eggs
1 cup half & half (or 1/2 cup whole milk and 1/2 cup cream)

1 tablespoon butter, melted
1 tablespoon brown sugar
1/8 teaspoon ground ginger
1/2 cup panko (what is panko?) or crisp bread crumbs
1/4 cup chopped toasted pecans

A handful of mini marshmallows (then throw away the rest so you're not tempted to eat the little pillows!)

SWEET POTATOES Place water and potatoes in a large pot and bring to a boil. Cover and cook til potatoes are soft and fully cooked. Drain in a colander.

Preheat oven to 375F.

In a large bowl, mix the potatoes, brown sugar, salt and vanilla with an electric mixer til smooth. (Be sure to work out the little nuggets of brown sugar, they'll burn.) Add the eggs and beat til smooth. Add the half & half and beat til smooth. (2007: The mixture may be quite runny. 2010: It wasn't runny at all. ) Transfer to a well-greased two-quart baking dish.

TOPPING Mix the topping ingredients.

BAKE Sprinkle the marshmallows over the top of the casserole, leaving room for the topping to be sprinkled in between. Bake for 30 - 45 minutes or until golden brown. Dig in!

THE DAY BEFORE Cook the sweet potatoes and mix the casserole and the topping but keep separate.
DAY OF Return to room temperature. Top with marshmallows and topping and bake until steamy hot in the center, 45 - 60 minutes.
LEFTOVER REPORT This warms up beautifully and may in fact taste better on Day Two and Three.

EXTRA LARGE SWEET POTATOES (2007) My grocery only had super-sized sweet potatoes when I made this. When peeling and cubing, I could tell they were woody, and while I don't know for sure, I do attribute this to size and would recommend sweet potatoes no bigger than 3/4 pound.
STEAMING vs BOILING (2007) The inspiring recipe called for boiling the potatoes. I thought this would add too much liquid to the casserole but afterward, now believe that steaming them didn't add enough liquid. Next time, I'll boil them. (2010) I did indeed boil the sweet potatoes and think that this is the right treatment.
SWEETNESS & RICHNESS I think that this recipe is good enough to play with, reducing the sweetness and richness and letting the sweet potatoes really come through. Next time, I will drop back to 1/4 cup of brown sugar and use whole milk rather than half & half. I'd also drop the vanilla back to just a teaspoon.

A Veggie Venture - Printer Friendly Recipe Graphic

Move aside, turkeys. (No, not you, dear readers! Thanksgiving turkeys!) Here at A Veggie Venture, vegetables are the real stars of the Thanksgiving table. So it's new Thanksgiving recipes all November long for a fabulous collection of Thanksgiving vegetable recipe ideas. Whether it's last year's famous World's Best Green Bean Casserole or a brand-new recipe which catches your fancy this year, move over turkeys, it's vegetables' time.
© Copyright 2007, 2014


I feel stupid but what is panko?

You know I do not cook enough with sweet potatoes - to break that rule I actually went out and bought a few today and now you post a lovely recipe idea. Sounds really good!

Thanks for all of your recipes- keep them coming!:-) One thing to note w/ marshmellows- most of them aren't vegetarian as they contain gelatin. For those strict vegetarians, this is an ingredient to avoid. There are vegan marshmellows available (no animal bi-product) but they are a little hard to find and I've only seen the large size marshmellows- never the minis.

Thanks again- looking forward to trying more of your recipes in the coming months.

Megan ~ Oh dear, don't feel stupid. Panko is one of those ingredients that once you find it, you'll make sure it's always in your pantry. It's bread crumbs, Japanese bread crumbs, that are rougher and crisper but still of consistent size, different than what we can make ourselves with good bread and a food processor.

Meeta ~ Good for you, m'dear!

Hi Anonymous ~ Thanks so much for the insight for the vegetarians and vegans who follow A Veggie Venture. Just to be clear (again, so many people wonder), A Veggie Venture is 100% vegetables but is not either vegetarian or vegan, even though naturally, many if not most recipes are indeed that. PS You're so welcome, your note means a lot to me, thank you.

Call me dumb but I never realised what a Northern Hemisphere "holiday food" sweet potatoes were! Please to know though as I love them. I have to admit being suspicious of the idea of marshmallows anywhere near my vegetables... but if you say it's ok...! :)

I reread your sweet potato casserole recipe, and noticed that it calls for 2 1/4 pounds sweet potatoes
and will serve 16 people. Is that correct?

Good question, Barbara ~ For "supper" portions, I nearly always allow 1/4 pound of vegetables per serving. But for these rich casseroles, especially if there are going to be lots of other dishes on the table, I cut that in half, assuming that people will take small spoonfuls of many dishes rather than a big spoonful of one.

Hope this helps --

I'm in charge of the sweet potatoes this Thanksgiving and am making this awesome recipe. My question is: Can I omit the pecans in the topping or can you suggest a subsitute for them?

Suzanne ~ Congratulations, you're planning way ahead! The pecans are optional, for sure, though they do provide a nice crunch that's a good texture contrast.

This was the BEST sweet potato casserole I've ever made and eaten! It was a huge hit for Thanksgiving - people ate seconds of this instead of dessert! My boyfriend said I could make this anytime, and he will be having it again tomorrow for dinner! THANKS!!

Post a Comment

Thank you for taking a moment to write! I read each and every comment, for each and every recipe, whether a current recipe or a long-ago favorite. If you have a specific question, it's nearly always answered quick-quick. ~ Alanna